SOPHIE M. GOLDFELD
Princeton University or college
DANIEL E. SICHEL*
Panel of Governors of the Federal government Reserve System
1 ) 2 .
Introduction Overview of empirical difficulties
installment payments on your 1 . installment payments on your 2 . U. S. cash demand Money demand: Intercontinental evidence A quick theoretical guide A variable-by-variable review Money demand plus the partial adjusting mechanism Criticisms and adjustments of the part adjustment version Dynamic designs that impose long-run human relationships Simultaneity, exogeneity, and the mother nature of the modification process
Re-examining the standard specification
3. 1 . several. 2 .
three hundred 302 302 306 308
4. 1 ) 4. 2 . 4. three or more. 4. 4.
5. Concluding remarks Recommendations
313 324 325 333 338 341 349 353
* We thank Benjamin Friedman pertaining to his feedback. The views expressed are those of the authors; they just do not necessarily reveal the opinions of the Plank of Governors of the Federal Reserve Program.
Handbook of Monetary Economics, Volume I, Edited by B. Meters. Friedman and F. They would. Hahn В© Elsevier Science Publishers M. V., 1990
T. M. Goldfeld and M. E. Sichel
I. Introduction The regards between the demand for money balances and its determinants is a fundamental building block generally in most theories of macroeconomic behavior. Indeed, many macroeconomic designs, whether theoretical or econometric, generally ignore the rich institutional detail of the financial sector and make an attempt to capture financial factors with the demand and provide of money. Furthermore, the demand for money is a critical component in the formulation of monetary policy and a reliable demand function for money is definitely perceived as a prerequisite for the use of monetary aggregates in the carry out of plan. Not surprisingly, in that case, the demand for money in many countries has been subjected to extensive empirical scrutiny. The evidence that emerged, at least before the mid-1970s, advised that a couple of variables (essentially income and interest rates, with appropriate allocated for lags) were capable of providing a plausible and stable reason of money demand. As continues to be widely documented, especially for the United States but anywhere else as well, issues have been noticeably less adequate since the mid-1970s. First, there were the instance of the " missing m o and e sumado a " when conventional cash demand equations systematically overpredicted actual cash balances. Furthermore, attempts to fit conventional demand functions into a sample that included the missing funds period invariably produced unbekannte estimates with a few quite irrational properties. Second, in the 1980s, U. S i9000. money require functions, if fixed up to explain the 1972s, generally displayed extended times of underprediction as discovered velocity droped markedly. To make certain, the period because the mid-1970s have been marked by simply unusual economical conditions in many countries including source shocks, extreme bouts an excellent source of and adjustable inflation, record-high interest rates, and deep recessions. The period as well coincided with the widespread usage of suspended exchange rates and, in several major commercial countries, with substantial institutional changes brought about by financial innovation and financial deregulation. Wherever institutional modify was specifically marked, additionally, it led to a change in what we believe of while " m o and e sumado a ". The time since 1974 thus presented a very extreme test of empirical cash demand human relationships and it is perhaps not so amazing that this period succeeded in exposing several shortcomings in existing requirements of money demand functions. 1 lit is perhaps ironic that the emergence of these shortcomings roughly coincided together with the adoption by a number of central banks of guidelines aimed at focusing on monetary aggregates. Some have got argued that the association is far more than pure coincidence. In any event, given the vested interest of policymakers in the lifestyle of a reliably stable...
References: Ando, A. and K. Shell (1975) 'Demand for cash in a standard portfolio model", in: The Brookings model: Perspective and recent developments. Amsterdam: North-Holland. Arango, S. and M. We. Nadiri (1981) 'The with regard to money in wide open economies", Record of Economic Economics, six: 69-84. Humor, Y., M. Hendry and R. Starr (1985) 'U. S. money demand, 1960-1984 ', mineo. Barnett, T. A. (1980) 'Economic monetary aggregates: A software of index number and aggregation theory ', Diary of Econometrics, 14: 11-48. Baumol, T. J. (1952) 'The deals demand for cash: An inventory theoretic approach ', Quarterly Record of Economics, 66: 545-556. Betancourt, L. and L. Kelejian (1981) 'Lagged endogenous variables plus the Cochrane-Orcutt process ', Econometrica, 49: 1073-1078. Black, H. W. (1973) 'Aggregation over time, the supply and demand for money, and monetary policy ', Special Research Paper, 35, Federal Arrange Board of Governors. Boughton, J. M. (1981) 'Recent instability from the demand for money: An international point of view ', The southern area of Economic Diary, 47: 579-591. Box, G. E. P. and M. R. Cox (1964) 'An analysis of transformations ', Journal with the Royal Statistical Society, Arranged. B, twenty six: 211-243. Boyes, W. M. (1978) 'An application of requirements error testing - the liquidity trap ', The Manchester College, 2: 139-151. Brainard, Watts. (1967) 'Uncertainty and the effectiveness of coverage ', AEA Papers and Proceedings, LVII: 411-425. Brainard, W. (1976) 'Discussion ', Brookings Papers on Monetary Activity, a few: 732-736. Buiter, W. L. and C. A. Armstrong (1978) 'A didactic be aware on the ventures demand for funds and patterns towards risk ', Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 10: 529-538. Cagan, G. (1984) 'Monetary policy and subduing inflation ', in: Essays in contemporary financial problems: Disinflation. Washington: American Enterprise Company. Carr, M. L. and M. 3rd there’s r. Darby (1981) 'The function of money supply shocks inside the short-run with regard to money ', Journal of Monetary Economics, 8: 183-199. Carr, J., M. L. Darby and D. Thornton (1985) 'Monetary anticipation plus the demand for money: Reply to MacKinnon and Milbourne ', Diary of Monetary Economics, 16: 251-257. Chant, J. F. (1976) 'Dynamic adjustments in simple models of the ventures demand for money ', Diary of Budgetary Economics, two: 351-366. Christiano, L. L. and Meters. Eichenbaum (1986) 'Temporal crowd and structural inference in macroeconomics ', NBER Technological Working Daily news 60. Layers, W. L. (1982) 'Modeling the short-run demand for funds with exogenous supply ', Economic Inquiry, XX: 222-239.
S. M. Goldfeld and M. E. Sichel
Cooley, Capital t. F. and S. N. LeRoy (1981) 'Identification and estimation of money demand ', American Economic Review, 71: 825-844. Corrado, C. and P. Spindt (1986) ' T versus Q: The measurement and analysis of monetary transactions ', mimeo. Cramer, J. A. (1986) 'The volume of transactions as well as the circulation of money in the United States, 1950-1979 ', Record of Organization and Economic Statistics, 4: 225-232. Cuthbertson, K. and M. L. Taylor (1986) 'Monetary anticipation and the with regard to money in the U. E.: Testing rationality in the shock-absorber hypothesis ', Journal of Applied Econometrics, 1: 355 -365. Dotsey, M. (1985) 'The make use of electronic cash transfers for capturing the effects of money management techniques on the with regard to demand deposit: A note ', Journal of Finance, forty: 1493-1504. Dutkowsky, D. H. and W. G. Foote (1987) 'The demand for funds: A logical expectations procedure ', Syracuse University, mimeo. Engle, R. F. and C. T. J. Granger (1987) 'Co-integration and error correction: Rendering, estimation and testing ', Econometrica, fifty-five: 251-276. Engle, R. F., D. F. Hendry and J. -F. Richard (1983) 'Exogeneity ', Econometrica, 51: 277-304. Fackler, J. and W. McMillan (1983) 'Specification and steadiness of the Goldfeld money require function ', Journal of Macroeconomics, a few: 437-459. Reasonable, R. C. (1987) 'International evidence around the demand for money ', Report on Economics and Statistics, LXIX: 473-480. Federal government Reserve, Panel of Governors (1987) 'Changes in the usage of transactions accounts and money from 1984 to 1986 ', Bulletins, 73: 179-196. Feige, E. L. (1967) 'Expectations and adjustments in the monetary sector ', American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings, 57: 462-473. Freedman, C. (1983) 'Financial creativity in Canada: Causes and effects ', American Economic Assessment, Papers and Proceedings, 73: 101-106. Friedman, B. Meters. (1977) 'Financial flow parameters and the short-run determination of long-term interest rates ', Journal of Politics Economy, eighty five: 661-689. Friedman, B. Meters. (1978) 'Crowding out or perhaps crowding in? Economic implications of funding government deficits ', Brookings Papers in Economic Activity, 3: 593-641. Friedman, M. (1956) 'The quantity theory of money: A restatement ', in: M. Friedman, ed., Studies inside the quantity theory of money. Chicago, il: Chicago University or college Press. Friedman, M. (1959) 'The with regard to money: Some theoretical and empirical outcomes ', Record of Personal Economy, 67: 327-351. Fnsselman, J. and Grossman, H. (1986) 'Monetary dynamics with fixed purchase costs ', Department of Economics, School of Chi town, mimeo. Garner, C. A. (1986) 'Does interest rate movements affect money demand? ', Economic Assessment, Federal Arrange Bank of Kansas City, 71: 25-37. Goldfeld, S. Meters. (1973) 'The demand for cash revisited ', Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, a few: 577-638. Goldfeld, S. M. (1976) 'The case from the missing cash ', Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 3: 683 -730. Goldfeld, S. and D. Sichel (1987a) 'Money demand: The consequence of inflation and alternative realignment mechanisms ', Review of Economics and Figures, 69: 511-515. Goldfeld, T. and Deb. Sichel (1987b) 'On the misuse of forecast problems to distinguish among level and first difference specifications ', Economics Words, 23: 173-176. Goodfriend, M. (1985) 'Reinterpreting money demand regressions ', in: E. Brunner and A. They would. Meltzer, eds., Understanding budgetary regimes, Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Community Policy, Volume. 22. Amsterdam: North-Holland. Gordon, R. J. (1981) 'Output fluctuations and gradual value adjustment ', Journal of Economic Literature, 19: 493-530. Gordon, R. J. (1984) 'The short-run demand for cash: A reconsideration ', Record of Money, Credit rating and Bank, 16: 403-434. Hafer, R. W. and S. E. Hein (1980) 'The characteristics and evaluation of short-run money require ', Federal Reserve Traditional bank of St Louis Assessment, 62: 26-35.
Ch. almost eight: The Demand for Money
Haler, R. W. and T. E. Oui (1982) 'The shift in money demand: What actually hapened? ', Federal Hold Bank of St . Louis Review, 64: 11-16. Burger, M. T. (1977) 'Behavior of the funds stock: ls there a puzzle? ', Journal of Monetary Economics, 3: 265-288. Hatanaka, M. (1974) 'An efficient two-step estimator for the dynamic adjustment model with autoregressive errors ', Journal of Econometrics, a couple of: 199-220. Likas?, H. R. and Meters. S. Khan (1979) 'The demand for funds and the term structure interesting rates ', Journal of Political Economic climate, 87: 109-129. Hendry, G. F. (1980) 'Predictive failure and econometric modelling in macroeconomics: The transactions demand for money ', in: Financial modeling. London, uk: Heincmann Education Books. Hetzel, R. M. (1984) 'Estimating money demand functions ', Journal pounds, Credit and Banking, 18: 185-193. Hwang, H. (1985) 'Test with the adjustment method and linear homogeneity in a stock adjustment model of funds demand ', The Review of Economics and Statistics, LXVII: 689-692. Judd, T. P. and J. L. Scadding (1982a) 'The visit a stable funds demand function: A review of the post-1973 literature ', Journal of Economic Materials, 20: 993-1023. Judd, P. and L. L. Scadding (1982b) 'Financial change and monetary targeting in the U. S. ', in: Interest deregulation and monetary coverage. Federal Hold Bank of San Francisco, pp. 78-106. Judd, J. S. and L. L. Scadding (1982c) 'Dynamic adjustment inside the demand for money: Tests of different hypotheses ', Economic Review, Federal Book Bank of San Francisco, Fall: 19-30. Keeley, M. C. and G. C. Zimmerman (1986) 'Deposit rate deregulation and the with regard to transactions multimedia ', Monetary Review, Federal government Reserve Bank of San Francisco, Summer: 47-62. Keil, M. and Watts. Richardson (1986) 'The with regard to money in Canada: Some scientific tests of lag buildings ', mimeo. Klein, W. (1974) 'Competitive interest payments about bank build up and the long-run demand for money ', American Economic Review, 64: 931-949. Laidler, Deb. E. T. (1984) 'The buffer stock notion in monetary economics ', Economical Journal, 94, Supplement: 17-33. Laidler, G. E. Watts. (1985) The necessity for money: Theories and proof, 3rd edn. New York: Dun-Donnelley. Lindsey, Deb. E. and P. A. Spindt (1986) 'An evaluation of financial indexes ', Special Studies Papers, 195, Federal Arrange Board. MacKinnon, J. G. and 3rd there’s r. D. Milbourne (1984) 'Monetary anticipations and the demand for cash ', Journal of Economic Economics, 13: 263-274. MacKinnon, J. G and Ur. D. Milbourne (1987) 'Are price equations really cash demand equations on their minds? ', mimeo. Mankiw, N. G. and L. L. Summers (1986) 'Money demand and the effects of fiscal plans ', Diary of Money, Credit rating and Bank, 18: 415-429. McCallum, B. T. and M. S. Goodfriend (1987) 'Money: Assumptive analysis from the demand for cash ', NBER Working Conventional paper 2157. Melnick, R. (1989) 'The demand for money in Spain 1978-1987 ', mimeo. Milbourne, R., G. Buckholtz and M. Big t. Wasan (1983) 'A theoretical derivation from the functional form of short-run cash holdings ', Review of Economical Studies, 55: 531-542. Miller, M. They would. and Daniel Orr (1966) 'A model of the demand for money by organizations ', Quarterly Journal of Economics, LXXX: 413-435. Mishkin, F. S i9000. (1983) A rational expectations approach to macroeconomics. Chicago: University Press, to get NBER. Moore, G. 3rd there’s r., R. D. Porter and D. They would. Small (1988) 'Modeling the disaggregated requirements for M2 and M1 in the 1980 's: The U. S. experience ', mimeo. Questionnable, A. Ur. (1984) 'Econometric issues in the analysis of regressions with generated regressors ', International Economic Review, 25: 221-247.
S i9000. M. Goldfeld and Deb. E. Sichel
Plosser, C. I., G. W. Schwert and L. White (1982) 'Differencing like a test of specification ', International Economical Review, twenty three: 535-552. Poole, W. (1970) 'Optimal choice of monetary insurance plan instruments within a simple stochastic macro unit ', Quarterly Journal of Economics, LXXIV: 197-216. Poole, W. (1987) 'Monetary coverage lessons of recent pumpiing and disinflation ', Functioning Paper 0010, National Bureau of Financial Research. Assurer, R. G. and Elizabeth. K. Offenbacher (1982) 'Financial innovations as well as the measurement of the money source ', Seminar on Economical Innovations, Government Reserve Bank of St Louis. Tenir, R. M., P. A. Spindt and D. At the. Lindsey (1987) 'Econometric building of the demands for the U. S i9000. monetary aggregates: Conventional and experimental techniques ', Special Studies Daily news 217, Government Reserve Plank of Governors. Radecki, T. J. and J. Wenninger (1985) 'Recent instability in Mls velocity ', National Reserve Bank of New You are able to Quarterly Review, 10: 16-22. Rasche, 3rd there’s r. H. (1987) 'Ml-velocity and money demand functions: Do stable interactions exist? ', Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Insurance plan. Roley, Versus. (1985) 'Money demand predictability ', Record of Money, Credit rating and Banking, 17: 611-641. Rose, A. (1985) 'An alternative method to the American demand for money ', Diary of Money, Credit and Financial, 17: 439-455. Santomero, A. M. and J. J. Siegel (1986) 'Deposit deregulation and economic policy ', CarnegieRochester Conference Series on Public Plan, pp. 179-224. Simpson, T. D. and R. G. Porter (1980) 'Some problems involving the classification and interpretation of the monetary aggregates ', Federal Hold Bank of Boston Meeting Series, 23: 161-234. Spencer, D. Elizabeth. (1985) 'Money demand as well as the price level ', Report on Economics and Statistics, 67: 490-495. Spindt, P. A. (1985) 'Money is what money does: Budgetary aggregation plus the equation of exchange ', Journal of Political Overall economy, 93: 175-204. Spindt, L. A. (1987) 'On the provision of the demand for money ', Special Research Paper, 215, Federal Reserve Board of Governors. Spitzer, J. M. (1976) 'The demand for money, the fluidity trap, and functional varieties ', Worldwide Economic Assessment, 17: 220-227. Startz, L. (1979) 'Implicit interest about demand build up ', Diary of Budgetary Economics, a few: 515-525. Swamy, P. A. V. W., A. M. Kennickell and P. von zur Muehlen (1986) 'Forecasting money demand with econometric models ', Special Research Paper, 196, Federal Hold Board. Thornton, D. L. (1982) 'Maximum likelihood estimations of a partial adjustment-adaptive expectations model of the need for money ', Review of Economics and Figures, LXIV: 325-329. Thornton, Deb. L. (1985) 'Money require dynamics: Some new evidence ', Federal Book Bank of St . John Review, 67: 14-23. Tobin, J. (1956) 'The fascination elasticity of transactions with regard to cash ', Review of Economics and Statistics, 38: 241-247. Tobin, M. (1958) 'Liquidity preference while behavior to risk ', Review of Monetary Studies, twenty-five: 65 -86. Walsh, C. (1984) 'Interest rate unpredictability and economic policy ', Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 18: 133-150. Walters, A. A. (1967) 'The demand for funds - the dynamic houses of the multiplier ', Record of Political Economy, seventy five: 293-298. Webster, C. (1981) 'The demand for money in quarterly models ', in: Process of a Seminar: Empirical Research on Funds Demand. Middle for study regarding American Business. Wenninger, L. and T. J. Radecki (1986) 'Financial transactions and the demand for MI ', Government Reserve Lender of New You are able to Quarterly Review, 11: 24-29. Wickens, Meters. and Big t. S. Breusch (1987) 'Dynamic specification, the long-run and the estimation of transformed regression models ', CREP Conversation Paper 154. Zarembka, G. (1968) 'Functional form inside the demand for cash ', Record of the American Statistical Association, 63: 502-511.